House of Commons
Finance (No.3) Bill report stage: New Clause 18
Division #290
08 January 2019
288
Ayes
311
Noes

Votes by party

There is a difference between the official result of this division based on the Teller's count and the number of Members recorded by the clerks. How does this happen?
Click the button to view an image of the chart to print or download:

Individual votes

The tellers for the Ayes were:
The following Members voted Aye to the question:
Abbott, Ms Diane
Labour
Abrahams, Debbie
Labour
Ali, Rushanara
Labour
Allin-Khan, Dr Rosena
Labour
Amesbury, Mike
Labour
Antoniazzi, Tonia
Labour
Ashworth, Jonathan
Labour (Co-op)
Austin, Ian
Labour
Bailey, Mr Adrian
Labour (Co-op)
Bardell, Hannah
Scottish National Party
Barron, Sir Kevin
Labour
Beckett, Margaret
Labour
Benn, Hilary
Labour
Berger, Luciana
Labour (Co-op)
Betts, Mr Clive
Labour
Black, Mhairi
Scottish National Party
Blackford, Ian
Scottish National Party
Blackman, Kirsty
Scottish National Party
Blackman-Woods, Dr Roberta
Labour
Blomfield, Paul
Labour
Brabin, Tracy
Labour (Co-op)
Bradshaw, Mr Ben
Labour
Brake, Tom
Liberal Democrat
Brennan, Kevin
Labour
Brock, Deidre
Scottish National Party
Brown, Alan
Scottish National Party
Brown, Lyn
Labour
Brown, Mr Nicholas
Labour
Bryant, Chris
Labour
Buck, Ms Karen
Labour
Burden, Richard
Labour
Burgon, Richard
Labour
Butler, Dawn
Labour
Byrne, Liam
Labour
Cable, Sir Vince
Liberal Democrat
Cadbury, Ruth
Labour
Cameron, Dr Lisa
Scottish National Party
Campbell, Sir Alan
Labour
Carden, Dan
Labour
Carmichael, Mr Alistair
Liberal Democrat
Champion, Sarah
Labour
Chapman, Douglas
Scottish National Party
Chapman, Jenny
Labour
Charalambous, Bambos
Labour
Cherry, Joanna
Scottish National Party
Clwyd, Ann
Labour
Coaker, Vernon
Labour
Coffey, Ann
Labour
Cooper, Julie
Labour
Cooper, Rosie
Labour
Cooper, Yvette
Labour
Corbyn, Jeremy
Labour
Cowan, Ronnie
Scottish National Party
Coyle, Neil
Labour
Crawley, Angela
Scottish National Party
Creagh, Mary
Labour
Creasy, Stella
Labour (Co-op)
Cruddas, Jon
Labour
Cummins, Judith
Labour
Cunningham, Alex
Labour
Cunningham, Mr Jim
Labour
Daby, Janet
Labour
Dakin, Nic
Labour
Davey, Sir Edward
Liberal Democrat
David, Wayne
Labour
Davies, Geraint
Labour (Co-op)
Day, Martyn
Scottish National Party
De Cordova, Marsha
Labour
De Piero, Gloria
Labour
Debbonaire, Thangam
Labour
Dent Coad, Emma
Labour
Dhesi, Mr Tanmanjeet Singh
Labour
Docherty-Hughes, Martin
Scottish National Party
Dodds, Anneliese
Labour (Co-op)
Doughty, Stephen
Labour (Co-op)
Dowd, Peter
Labour
Drew, Dr David
Labour (Co-op)
Duffield, Rosie
Labour
Eagle, Maria
Labour
Eagle, Ms Angela
Labour
Edwards, Jonathan
Plaid Cymru
Efford, Clive
Labour
Elliott, Julie
Labour
Ellman, Dame Louise
Labour (Co-op)
Elmore, Chris
Labour
Esterson, Bill
Labour
Evans, Chris
Labour (Co-op)
Farrelly, Paul
Labour
Farron, Tim
Liberal Democrat
Fitzpatrick, Jim
Labour
Fletcher, Colleen
Labour
Flint, Caroline
Labour
Fovargue, Yvonne
Labour
Foxcroft, Vicky
Labour
Frith, James
Labour
Furniss, Gill
Labour
Gaffney, Hugh
Labour
Gapes, Mike
Labour (Co-op)
Gardiner, Barry
Labour
George, Ruth
Labour
Gethins, Stephen
Scottish National Party
Gibson, Patricia
Scottish National Party
Gill, Preet Kaur
Labour (Co-op)
Glindon, Mary
Labour
Godsiff, Mr Roger
Labour
Goodman, Helen
Labour
Grant, Peter
Scottish National Party
Gray, Neil
Scottish National Party
Green, Kate
Labour
Greenwood, Lilian
Labour
Greenwood, Margaret
Labour
Griffith, Nia
Labour
Grogan, John
Labour
Gwynne, Andrew
Labour
Haigh, Louise
Labour
Hamilton, Fabian
Labour
Hanson, David
Labour
Hardy, Emma
Labour
Harman, Ms Harriet
Labour
Harris, Carolyn
Labour
Hayes, Helen
Labour
Hayman, Sue
Labour
Healey, John
Labour
Hendrick, Sir Mark
Labour (Co-op)
Hendry, Drew
Scottish National Party
Hepburn, Mr Stephen
Labour
Hermon, Lady
Independent
Hill, Mike
Labour
Hillier, Meg
Labour (Co-op)
Hobhouse, Wera
Liberal Democrat
Hodgson, Mrs Sharon
Labour
Hollern, Kate
Labour
Hopkins, Kelvin
Independent
Hosie, Stewart
Scottish National Party
Huq, Dr Rupa
Labour
Hussain, Imran
Labour
Jardine, Christine
Liberal Democrat
Johnson, Diana
Labour
Jones, Darren
Labour
Jones, Gerald
Labour
Jones, Helen
Labour
Jones, Mr Kevan
Labour
Jones, Sarah
Labour
Jones, Susan Elan
Labour
Kane, Mike
Labour
Keeley, Barbara
Labour
Kendall, Liz
Labour
Khan, Afzal
Labour
Killen, Ged
Labour (Co-op)
Kinnock, Stephen
Labour
Kyle, Peter
Labour
Laird, Lesley
Labour
Lake, Ben
Plaid Cymru
Lamb, Norman
Liberal Democrat
Lammy, Mr David
Labour
Lavery, Ian
Labour
Law, Chris
Scottish National Party
Lee, Karen
Labour
Leslie, Mr Chris
Labour (Co-op)
Lewell-Buck, Mrs Emma
Labour
Lewis, Clive
Labour
Linden, David
Scottish National Party
Lloyd, Tony
Labour
Long Bailey, Rebecca
Labour
Lucas, Caroline
Green Party
Lucas, Ian C.
Labour
MacNeil, Angus Brendan
Scottish National Party
Madders, Justin
Labour
Mahmood, Mr Khalid
Labour
Mahmood, Shabana
Labour
Malhotra, Seema
Labour (Co-op)
Mann, John
Labour
Marsden, Gordon
Labour
Martin, Sandy
Labour
Maskell, Rachael
Labour (Co-op)
Matheson, Christian
Labour
McCabe, Steve
Labour
McCarthy, Kerry
Labour
McDonagh, Siobhain
Labour
McDonald, Andy
Labour
McDonald, Stewart Malcolm
Scottish National Party
McDonald, Stuart C.
Scottish National Party
McDonnell, John
Labour
McFadden, Mr Pat
Labour
McGinn, Conor
Labour
McGovern, Alison
Labour
McInnes, Liz
Labour
McKinnell, Catherine
Labour
McMahon, Jim
Labour (Co-op)
McMorrin, Anna
Labour
McNally, John
Scottish National Party
Mearns, Ian
Labour
Miliband, Edward
Labour
Monaghan, Carol
Scottish National Party
Moran, Layla
Liberal Democrat
Morden, Jessica
Labour
Morgan, Stephen
Labour
Morris, Grahame
Labour
Murray, Ian
Labour
Nandy, Lisa
Labour
Newlands, Gavin
Scottish National Party
Norris, Alex
Labour (Co-op)
O'Hara, Brendan
Scottish National Party
O'Mara, Jared
Independent
Onn, Melanie
Labour
Onwurah, Chi
Labour
Osamor, Kate
Labour (Co-op)
Owen, Albert
Labour
Peacock, Stephanie
Labour
Pearce, Teresa
Labour
Pennycook, Matthew
Labour
Perkins, Toby
Labour
Phillips, Jess
Labour
Phillipson, Bridget
Labour
Pidcock, Laura
Labour
Platt, Jo
Labour (Co-op)
Pollard, Luke
Labour (Co-op)
Pound, Stephen
Labour
Powell, Lucy
Labour (Co-op)
Qureshi, Yasmin
Labour
Rashid, Faisal
Labour
Rayner, Angela
Labour
Reed, Mr Steve
Labour (Co-op)
Rees, Christina
Labour (Co-op)
Reeves, Ellie
Labour
Reeves, Rachel
Labour
Reynolds, Emma
Labour
Reynolds, Jonathan
Labour (Co-op)
Rimmer, Ms Marie
Labour
Rodda, Matt
Labour
Rowley, Danielle
Labour
Ruane, Chris
Labour
Russell-Moyle, Lloyd
Labour (Co-op)
Ryan, Joan
Labour
Saville Roberts, Liz
Plaid Cymru
Sharma, Mr Virendra
Labour
Sheerman, Mr Barry
Labour (Co-op)
Sheppard, Tommy
Scottish National Party
Sherriff, Paula
Labour
Shuker, Mr Gavin
Labour (Co-op)
Skinner, Mr Dennis
Labour
Slaughter, Andy
Labour
Smeeth, Ruth
Labour
Smith, Angela
Labour
Smith, Cat
Labour
Smith, Eleanor
Labour
Smith, Jeff
Labour
Smith, Laura
Labour
Smith, Nick
Labour
Smith, Owen
Labour
Smyth, Karin
Labour
Snell, Gareth
Labour (Co-op)
Sobel, Alex
Labour (Co-op)
Spellar, John
Labour
Starmer, Keir
Labour
Stephens, Chris
Scottish National Party
Stevens, Jo
Labour
Stone, Jamie
Liberal Democrat
Streeting, Wes
Labour
Stringer, Graham
Labour
Sweeney, Mr Paul
Labour (Co-op)
Swinson, Jo
Liberal Democrat
Tami, Mark
Labour
Thewliss, Alison
Scottish National Party
Thomas, Gareth
Labour (Co-op)
Thomas-Symonds, Nick
Labour
Timms, Stephen
Labour
Trickett, Jon
Labour
Turley, Anna
Labour (Co-op)
Turner, Karl
Labour
Twigg, Derek
Labour
Twigg, Stephen
Labour (Co-op)
Twist, Liz
Labour
Umunna, Chuka
Labour
Vaz, Valerie
Labour
Walker, Thelma
Labour
Watson, Tom
Labour
West, Catherine
Labour
Western, Matt
Labour
Whitehead, Dr Alan
Labour
Whitfield, Martin
Labour
Whitford, Dr Philippa
Scottish National Party
Williams, Dr Paul
Labour
Williams, Hywel
Plaid Cymru
Williamson, Chris
Labour
Wilson, Phil
Labour
Wishart, Pete
Scottish National Party
Yasin, Mohammad
Labour
Zeichner, Daniel
Labour
The tellers for the Noes were:
The following Members voted No to the question:
Adams, Nigel
Conservative
Afolami, Bim
Conservative
Afriyie, Adam
Conservative
Aldous, Peter
Conservative
Allan, Lucy
Conservative
Allen, Heidi
Conservative
Amess, Sir David
Conservative
Andrew, Stuart
Conservative
Argar, Edward
Conservative
Atkins, Victoria
Conservative
Bacon, Mr Richard
Conservative
Badenoch, Mrs Kemi
Conservative
Baker, Mr Steve
Conservative
Baldwin, Harriett
Conservative
Barclay, Stephen
Conservative
Baron, Mr John
Conservative
Bebb, Guto
Conservative
Bellingham, Sir Henry
Conservative
Benyon, Richard
Conservative
Beresford, Sir Paul
Conservative
Berry, Jake
Conservative
Blackman, Bob
Conservative
Blunt, Crispin
Conservative
Boles, Nick
Conservative
Bone, Mr Peter
Conservative
Bottomley, Sir Peter
Conservative
Bowie, Andrew
Conservative
Bradley, Ben
Conservative
Bradley, Karen
Conservative
Brady, Sir Graham
Conservative
Braverman, Suella
Conservative
Brereton, Jack
Conservative
Bridgen, Andrew
Conservative
Brine, Steve
Conservative
Brokenshire, James
Conservative
Bruce, Fiona
Conservative
Buckland, Robert
Conservative
Burghart, Alex
Conservative
Burns, Conor
Conservative
Burt, Alistair
Conservative
Cairns, Alun
Conservative
Campbell, Mr Gregory
Democratic Unionist Party
Cartlidge, James
Conservative
Cash, Sir William
Conservative
Caulfield, Maria
Conservative
Chalk, Alex
Conservative
Chishti, Rehman
Conservative
Chope, Sir Christopher
Conservative
Churchill, Jo
Conservative
Clark, Colin
Conservative
Clark, Greg
Conservative
Clarke, Mr Kenneth
Conservative
Clarke, Mr Simon
Conservative
Cleverly, James
Conservative
Clifton-Brown, Sir Geoffrey
Conservative
Coffey, Dr Thérèse
Conservative
Collins, Damian
Conservative
Costa, Alberto
Conservative
Courts, Robert
Conservative
Cox, Mr Geoffrey
Conservative
Crabb, Stephen
Conservative
Crouch, Tracey
Conservative
Davies, Chris
Conservative
Davies, David T. C.
Conservative
Davies, Glyn
Conservative
Davies, Mims
Conservative
Davies, Philip
Conservative
Davis, Mr David
Conservative
Dinenage, Caroline
Conservative
Djanogly, Mr Jonathan
Conservative
Docherty, Leo
Conservative
Dodds, Nigel
Democratic Unionist Party
Donaldson, Sir Jeffrey M.
Democratic Unionist Party
Donelan, Michelle
Conservative
Double, Steve
Conservative
Dowden, Oliver
Conservative
Doyle-Price, Jackie
Conservative
Drax, Richard
Conservative
Duddridge, James
Conservative
Duguid, David
Conservative
Duncan Smith, Mr Iain
Conservative
Duncan, Sir Alan
Conservative
Dunne, Mr Philip
Conservative
Ellis, Michael
Conservative
Ellwood, Mr Tobias
Conservative
Elphicke, Charlie
Conservative
Eustice, George
Conservative
Evans, Mr Nigel
Conservative
Evennett, Sir David
Conservative
Fabricant, Michael
Conservative
Fallon, Sir Michael
Conservative
Field, Mark
Conservative
Ford, Vicky
Conservative
Foster, Kevin
Conservative
Francois, Mr Mark
Conservative
Frazer, Lucy
Conservative
Freeman, George
Conservative
Freer, Mike
Conservative
Fysh, Mr Marcus
Conservative
Gale, Sir Roger
Conservative
Garnier, Mark
Conservative
Gauke, Mr David
Conservative
Ghani, Ms Nusrat
Conservative
Gibb, Nick
Conservative
Gillan, Dame Cheryl
Conservative
Girvan, Paul
Democratic Unionist Party
Glen, John
Conservative
Goldsmith, Zac
Conservative
Goodwill, Mr Robert
Conservative
Gove, Michael
Conservative
Graham, Luke
Conservative
Graham, Richard
Conservative
Grant, Bill
Conservative
Grant, Mrs Helen
Conservative
Gray, James
Conservative
Grayling, Chris
Conservative
Green, Chris
Conservative
Green, Damian
Conservative
Greening, Justine
Conservative
Grieve, Mr Dominic
Conservative
Griffiths, Andrew
Conservative
Gyimah, Mr Sam
Conservative
Hair, Kirstene
Conservative
Halfon, Robert
Conservative
Hammond, Mr Philip
Conservative
Hammond, Stephen
Conservative
Hancock, Matt
Conservative
Hands, Greg
Conservative
Harper, Mr Mark
Conservative
Harrington, Richard
Conservative
Harris, Rebecca
Conservative
Harrison, Trudy
Conservative
Hart, Simon
Conservative
Hayes, Sir John
Conservative
Heald, Sir Oliver
Conservative
Heappey, James
Conservative
Heaton-Harris, Chris
Conservative
Heaton-Jones, Peter
Conservative
Henderson, Gordon
Conservative
Herbert, Nick
Conservative
Hoare, Simon
Conservative
Hollinrake, Kevin
Conservative
Hollobone, Mr Philip
Conservative
Holloway, Adam
Conservative
Howell, John
Conservative
Huddleston, Nigel
Conservative
Hughes, Eddie
Conservative
Hunt, Mr Jeremy
Conservative
Hurd, Mr Nick
Conservative
Jack, Mr Alister
Conservative
James, Margot
Conservative
Javid, Sajid
Conservative
Jayawardena, Mr Ranil
Conservative
Jenkin, Sir Bernard
Conservative
Jenkyns, Andrea
Conservative
Jenrick, Robert
Conservative
Johnson, Boris
Conservative
Johnson, Dr Caroline
Conservative
Johnson, Gareth
Conservative
Jones, Andrew
Conservative
Jones, Mr David
Conservative
Jones, Mr Marcus
Conservative
Kawczynski, Daniel
Conservative
Keegan, Gillian
Conservative
Kennedy, Seema
Conservative
Kerr, Stephen
Conservative
Knight, Julian
Conservative
Knight, Sir Greg
Conservative
Kwarteng, Kwasi
Conservative
Lamont, John
Conservative
Lancaster, Mark
Conservative
Latham, Mrs Pauline
Conservative
Leadsom, Andrea
Conservative
Lee, Dr Phillip
Conservative
Leigh, Sir Edward
Conservative
Letwin, Sir Oliver
Conservative
Lewer, Andrew
Conservative
Lewis, Brandon
Conservative
Lewis, Dr Julian
Conservative
Liddell-Grainger, Mr Ian
Conservative
Lidington, Mr David
Conservative
Little Pengelly, Emma
Democratic Unionist Party
Lopez, Julia
Conservative
Lopresti, Jack
Conservative
Lord, Mr Jonathan
Conservative
Loughton, Tim
Conservative
Mackinlay, Craig
Conservative
Maclean, Rachel
Conservative
Main, Mrs Anne
Conservative
Mak, Alan
Conservative
Malthouse, Kit
Conservative
Mann, Scott
Conservative
Masterton, Paul
Conservative
Maynard, Paul
Conservative
McLoughlin, Sir Patrick
Conservative
McPartland, Stephen
Conservative
McVey, Esther
Conservative
Menzies, Mark
Conservative
Mercer, Johnny
Conservative
Merriman, Huw
Conservative
Metcalfe, Stephen
Conservative
Miller, Mrs Maria
Conservative
Milling, Amanda
Conservative
Mills, Nigel
Conservative
Milton, Anne
Conservative
Mitchell, Mr Andrew
Conservative
Moore, Damien
Conservative
Mordaunt, Penny
Conservative
Morgan, Nicky
Conservative
Morris, Anne Marie
Conservative
Morris, David
Conservative
Morris, James
Conservative
Mundell, David
Conservative
Murray, Mrs Sheryll
Conservative
Murrison, Dr Andrew
Conservative
Neill, Robert
Conservative
Newton, Sarah
Conservative
Nokes, Caroline
Conservative
Norman, Jesse
Conservative
O'Brien, Neil
Conservative
Offord, Dr Matthew
Conservative
Opperman, Guy
Conservative
Paisley, Ian
Democratic Unionist Party
Parish, Neil
Conservative
Patel, Priti
Conservative
Paterson, Mr Owen
Conservative
Pawsey, Mark
Conservative
Penning, Sir Mike
Conservative
Penrose, John
Conservative
Percy, Andrew
Conservative
Perry, Claire
Conservative
Philp, Chris
Conservative
Pincher, Christopher
Conservative
Poulter, Dr Dan
Conservative
Prentis, Victoria
Conservative
Prisk, Mr Mark
Conservative
Pritchard, Mark
Conservative
Pursglove, Tom
Conservative
Quin, Jeremy
Conservative
Raab, Dominic
Conservative
Redwood, John
Conservative
Rees-Mogg, Mr Jacob
Conservative
Robertson, Mr Laurence
Conservative
Robinson, Gavin
Democratic Unionist Party
Robinson, Mary
Conservative
Rosindell, Andrew
Conservative
Ross, Douglas
Conservative
Rowley, Lee
Conservative
Rudd, Amber
Conservative
Rutley, David
Conservative
Sandbach, Antoinette
Conservative
Scully, Paul
Conservative
Seely, Mr Bob
Conservative
Selous, Andrew
Conservative
Shannon, Jim
Democratic Unionist Party
Shapps, Grant
Conservative
Sharma, Alok
Conservative
Shelbrooke, Alec
Conservative
Simpson, David
Democratic Unionist Party
Simpson, Mr Keith
Conservative
Skidmore, Chris
Conservative
Smith, Chloe
Conservative
Smith, Julian
Conservative
Smith, Royston
Conservative
Soames, Sir Nicholas
Conservative
Spencer, Mark
Conservative
Stephenson, Andrew
Conservative
Stevenson, John
Conservative
Stewart, Bob
Conservative
Stewart, Rory
Conservative
Streeter, Sir Gary
Conservative
Stride, Mel
Conservative
Stuart, Graham
Conservative
Sturdy, Julian
Conservative
Sunak, Rishi
Conservative
Swayne, Sir Desmond
Conservative
Swire, Sir Hugo
Conservative
Syms, Sir Robert
Conservative
Thomas, Derek
Conservative
Thomson, Ross
Conservative
Throup, Maggie
Conservative
Tolhurst, Kelly
Conservative
Tomlinson, Justin
Conservative
Tomlinson, Michael
Conservative
Tracey, Craig
Conservative
Tredinnick, David
Conservative
Trevelyan, Anne-Marie
Conservative
Truss, Elizabeth
Conservative
Tugendhat, Tom
Conservative
Vaizey, Mr Edward
Conservative
Vara, Mr Shailesh
Conservative
Vickers, Martin
Conservative
Villiers, Theresa
Conservative
Walker, Mr Charles
Conservative
Walker, Mr Robin
Conservative
Wallace, Mr Ben
Conservative
Warburton, David
Conservative
Warman, Matt
Conservative
Watling, Giles
Conservative
Whately, Helen
Conservative
Wheeler, Mrs Heather
Conservative
Whittaker, Craig
Conservative
Whittingdale, Mr John
Conservative
Wiggin, Bill
Conservative
Williamson, Gavin
Conservative
Wilson, Sammy
Democratic Unionist Party
Wollaston, Dr Sarah
Conservative
Wood, Mike
Conservative
Wragg, Mr William
Conservative
Wright, Jeremy
Conservative
Zahawi, Nadhim
Conservative
The following Members did not have a vote recorded and were not tellers. This can be due to a number of reasons; The Speaker and deputies do not vote, and Sinn Fein Members have an absentionist policy. A Member may wish to abstain, or have a procedural reason for not voting. Members can be absent carrying out consitituency or ministerial business, or be unable to attend for other reasons.